| In My Day of Trouble | Greg Jehanian | | Lyrics | In My Day of Trouble by Greg Jehanian | No Recording |
| In My Soul | | | Lyrics | In My Soul | No Recording |
| In The Sweet By and By | Sanford F. Bennet & Joseph P. Webster | | Lyrics | In The Sweet By and By by Sanford F. Bennet & Joseph P. Webster | No Recording |
| In Your Eyes | Peter Gabriel | www.youtube.com | Lyrics | In Your Eyes by Peter Gabriel | |
| In a Dry and Weary Land | Dan Snook | | Lyrics | In a Dry and Weary Land by Dan Snook | No Recording |
| In the Arms of the Lord | Seth Beiler and Justin Hollinger | | Lyrics | In the Arms of the Lord by Seth Beiler and Justin Hollinger | No Recording |
| In the Bleak Midwinter | Christina Rossetti | www.youtube.com | Lyrics | In the Bleak Midwinter by Christina Rossetti | |
| In the Darkest Time of Night | Jonny Szczesniak | | Lyrics | In the Darkest Time of Night by Jonny Szczesniak | No Recording |
| In the Day (Say it Right) | Nelly Furtado and Rod White | www.youtube.com | Lyrics | In the Day (Say it Right) by Nelly Furtado and Rod White | |
| In the Garden | C. Austin Miles | www.youtube.com | Lyrics | In the Garden by C. Austin Miles | |
| In the Mind of the Maker | Anita Brown and Jenny Florinicia | | Lyrics | In the Mind of the Maker by Anita Brown and Jenny Florinicia | No Recording |
| In the Secret | Andy Park | www.youtube.com | Lyrics | In the Secret by Andy Park | |
| In the Valley | Susie Moore | | Lyrics | In the Valley by Susie Moore | No Recording |
| Indescribable | Chris Tomlin | www.youtube.com | Lyrics | Indescribable by Chris Tomlin | |
| Infant Holy Infant Lowly | Piesni Koscielne | www.youtube.com | Lyrics | Infant Holy Infant Lowly by Piesni Koscielne | |
| Instrument for You | The Vespers | www.youtube.com | Lyrics | Instrument for You by The Vespers | |
| Ishwarle | Aradhna | www.aradhnamusic.com | Lyrics | Ishwarle by Aradhna | |
| Isn't He? | John Wimber | | Lyrics | Isn't He? by John Wimber | No Recording |
| Israel Will Fall and Rise | Angie Backues Petersen | | Lyrics | Israel Will Fall and Rise by Angie Backues Petersen | No Recording |
| It Came Upon the Midnight Clear | Edmund Sears | | Lyrics | It Came Upon the Midnight Clear by Edmund Sears | No Recording |
| It Feels Fine | The Beatles | | Lyrics | It Feels Fine by The Beatles | No Recording |
| It Is Well with My Soul | Horatio Spafford, Philip Bliss | www.youtube.com | Lyrics | It Is Well with My Soul by Horatio Spafford, Philip Bliss | |
| It Is You | Newsboys | www.youtube.com | Lyrics | It Is You by Newsboys | |
| It's Ok | Mutemath | www.youtube.com | Lyrics | It's Ok by Mutemath | |
| It's You I Like | Fred Rogers | www.youtube.com | | It's You I Like by Fred Rogers | No Lyrics |
